Home MANUEL REGO vs. THOMAS BROTHERS CORPORATION.

340 Mass. 334

December 9, 1959 - February 3, 1960

Bristol County

Present: WILKINS, C.J., SPALDING, COUNIHAN, WHITTEMORE, & CUTTER, JJ.

A corporation engaged in highway construction work might properly be found liable to one whom its superintendent of the work assaulted during an altercation between the superintendent and him respecting the removal of some boulders which had rolled onto land adjacent to the highway during the work and which the engineer in charge had ordered the superintendent to remove.

TORT. Writ in the Superior Court dated July 9, 1957.

There was a verdict for the plaintiff at the trial before Cahill, J.

William F. Hallisey, for the defendant.

Gerald P. Walsh, for the plaintiff.


COUNIHAN, J. In this action of tort the plaintiff seeks to recover damages for personal injuries sustained on May 20, 1957, as the result of an altercation between the plaintiff and one Clark, an employee of the defendant. The action comes here upon the exception of the defendant to the denial of its motion for a directed verdict. There was no error.

The evidence, in its aspects most favorable to the plaintiff, showed that Clark was employed by the defendant as superintendent of construction work on a public highway in the city of New Bedford, known as Phillips Road. During the course of the work several large boulders had rolled onto land of a Mrs. Sylvia abutting the highway. She was a niece of the plaintiff who lived with her in a house on this land.

On the morning of the day of the assault Mrs. Sylvia met Clark and ordered him to remove the boulders from this land. Upon his refusal to do so, she complained to the State

Page 335

engineer in charge of the job. He thereupon ordered Clark to remove the boulders and carry them off to a dump. As a result Clark returned to Mrs. Sylvia's land with two other employees of the defendant and began the work of removing the boulders.

Mrs. Sylvia appeared and told Clark that she had changed her mind and to stop. While she and Clark were arguing about it, the plaintiff came onto the land and ran up to Clark and in a loud voice told Clark to leave the boulders where they were. An altercation followed during which Clark struck the plaintiff two severe blows on his face breaking his jaw. Clark was forty-eight years old, about six feet in height, and weighed one hundred ninety pounds. The plaintiff was sixty-five years old, about five feet five inches in height, and weighed one hundred twenty-two pounds. The plaintiff testified that he never struck or attempted to strike Clark.

It was early said in Levi v. Brooks, 121 Mass. 501 , at page 505, "The test of the liability of the master is, that the act of the servant is done in the course of doing the master's work, and for the purpose of accomplishing it. If so done it is the act of the master, and he is responsible `whether the wrong done be occasioned by negligence, or by a wanton and reckless purpose to accomplish the master's business in an unlawful manner.'" See Robinson v. Doe, 224 Mass. 319 ; Ciarmataro v. Adams, 275 Mass. 521 , 526; Fanciullo v. B. G. & S. Theatre Corp. 297 Mass. 44 , 47; Cowan v. Eastern Racing Assn. Inc. 330 Mass. 135 , 141.

Exceptions overruled.